The least attractive element of the Internet's culture of conversation has been the all-too-frequent disregard for basic accountability in the commentary attached to stories, topics, images and discussions.

For some reason, anonymity is acceptable --- not as the justifiable shield for those who fear retribution if identified, but as a shield for those with other kinds of fears, motives or tendencies. Somewhere early in the game it became a rule instead of an exception to adopt a nickname and speak through it.

The result breaks what we were all taught rightly in school: That part of the bargain in speaking freely is the responsibility to stand up and be counted, and that part of the bargain in being criticized is to at least know who is attacking.

It's heartening, then, to read J.R. Johnson, the CEO of the social sharing service Lunch.com, observe in the San Jose Mercury News a shift to more accountability in comments online. He believes, and I agree, that more transparency among contributors and commenters will spur more participation; at the moment, many are keeping out of the fray because the unattributed cohort is given a long leash.

Ultimately the benefit will outweigh the detriment in making visible all but a handful --- those who truly need the protection.
 


Comments

Smalltown NB

Sun, 13 Sep 2009 16:01:58

Without anonymity people would not comment. True opinions would not be known. Here in NB for instance...if you were an Irving Employee or contractor...you can not freely state your comments.

 

Well, if I were being criticized, I would want to know who was doing it.

Sun, 13 Sep 2009 21:12:17

 

Smalltown NB

Mon, 14 Sep 2009 05:34:19

That is true - I have been on both sides. Recently accused by someone quoted in the paper as 'fabricating' something. I have all info to back up anything I say...but yet the Irving owned newspaper allowed the person saying 'fabricating' to remain anonymous.
That is okay with me though. There have been times I have been able to say more..without risking my job, because I have been anonymous.
It will be interesting to watch particularly the Irving Papers - as their new staff now says they will no longer allow anonymous comments.

 

Mon, 14 Sep 2009 09:45:16

I started writing a comment on this but, as sometimes happens, it became a blog post:

http://bit.ly/bACNX

 



Leave a Reply


DA25E68FDEC14EAFA7B2A27D26C48058