Paul Carr on anonymous blog posts 08/12/2009
A central dilemma in legacy media's efforts in digital journalism is how to deal with differing cultures of the platforms. Paid versus free, for instance. One-to-many versus many-to-many. And transparent versus anonymous. The ability for people to shield their identities in posting and commenting online poses a challenge for many media organizations steeped on the discipline of verification and the discretion of concealment. The Daily Telegraph's Paul Carr, always a thoughtful writer, weighs in with a blog/essay that outlines many of the core issues in the debate still coursing through newsrooms of what to do about the anonymous. Is anonymity an abuse of privilege or a basic right of privacy? From what I can tell, few newsrooms have settled the matter and left an incongruence in their operations. Namely, letter-writers are identified and checked and commenters could be anyone. It seems, as Carr suggests, that the time has come for a greater focus on this issue --- not to curtail the liveliness of the Internet but to strengthen its credibility. Indeed, Carr believes that recommendation algorithms are needed to help the situation --- trust-building gauges of our reputations and records as contributors, in essence. What do you think? Comments welcome, particularly from those who will stand and be counted. 1 Comment The conventional wisdom that the blogosphere is the publishing equivalent of the Wild West --- anything goes, no sheriff in town, and the like --- is overblown. But the criticism is often apt that there is little consumer protection from veiled self-serving content posing as legitimate information. Today the U.S. National Advertising Council indicated it intends to require disclosure when blogs are sponsored or product reviews are paid for on sites. It's a venture into regulation that suggests the community isn't fully capable of policing itself but needs some protection to ensure consumer integrity. The principle is simple: Advertising needs to be identified as such. The problem is that the ruling will impose voluntary guidelines, although complaints about the program can be referred to the Federal Trade Commission. The New York Times explores the issue today. The release by the council is expected later Tuesday. Introducing the Community of Interest 08/06/2009
We formally launched today our new Community of Interest site at vancouversun.com, a collection of blogs from dozens of local experts and our latest entry into so-called pro-am journalism. We believe the expertise from our contributors will enhance the quality of our news organization, provide timely writing on relevant issues, widen the conversation in our community on public affairs, and diversify available perspectives. Many are familiar voices as regular opinion-editorial contributors to the newspaper, but others are new to the scene for us. We were heartened by their willingness to participate regularly as bloggers, and by the range of leadership we're able to launch with, and thank them for committing the energy to the success of Community of Interest. Some of their work, and some of the comments about it, will be reverse-published into the newspaper to strengthen our local capabilities. We are open to many others joining us --- there are many gaps to fill --- and will be augmenting the roster in the time ahead. Comments and suggestions welcome. The Associated Press has been sending signals for months that it intends to get serious about ensuring its content isn't freely shared. Now it has seemingly set a rate card, and it's a strong message to those who would cut and paste its material. Mashable obtained the rate card, which takes effect supposedly when bloggers or others use more than five words of an AP story. The charge: $12.50 for those five words. A sliding scale rises to $100 for the use of more than 250 words. There are some discounts for educational and non-profit sectors. Michael Massing on the Internet and news 07/25/2009
The New York Review of Books is publishing a series of essays from the respected journalist Michael Massing. The first is a thoughtfully researched look at the evolution of the blog in the context of news and information provided through the Internet. If digital advertising is dramatically lower-priced than legacy advertising in reaching an individual, then it only makes sense to wring any costs associated with advertising out of the system. One such cost is building ads with creative departments or agencies. A study for the U.S. Institute for Public Relations suggests an increasing impact of social media but an enduring challenge for it to achieve credibility. Salon features a book excerpt from Scott Rosenberg, an essay on how blogs have changed everything. It's an argument that legacy media miscalculated the Web and continues to miscalculate the value of the voices blogs bring. Alan Mutter, in Reflections of a Newsosaur, questions the viability of grassroots journalism. He suggests that it isn't sustainable economically so won't develop professionally in a form that reliably serves society. INMA's Earl Wilkinson joins the blogosphere 06/22/2009
The Earl Blog is the creation of Earl Wilkinson, the respected executive director of the International Newsmedia Marketing Association (INMA), and it ought to be a substantial addition to the blogosphere. |
I am the Ombudsman of the CBC and Executive-in-Residence as an Adjunct Professor at the Graduate School of Journalism at University of British Columbia.
In 2008 I launched themediamanager.com to keep abreast of significant change in media. Since I moved to the Ombudsman's role, I have shifted the focus of the blog to media ethics. Intentionally you will not find my opinions here. Any such views should not be inferred as my employer's. I have held the senior editorial roles at The Vancouver Sun, CTV News, The Hamilton Spectator and Southam News. I am the founding Executive Editor of National Post, a former Ottawa Bureau Chief and General News Editor at The Canadian Press, and host on CBC Newsworld. My social networking includes activity on Twitter, Facebook and Linkedin. ArchivesFebruary 2012 CategoriesAll The Canadian analytics firm Sysomos has published new data on nearly 100 million posts it reviewed and it shows
|
RSS Feed

